{
  "schema": "por-derecho.r33-truth-machine-visual.v1",
  "control": "PD-R33-TRUTH-MACHINE-20260925-01",
  "generated_from": {
    "document_id": "C36-SPECIALIST-R33",
    "native_pdf_sha256": "5e0728185cf9b686abd723497d2a53a2656a5e0de4d323a734ed02880eb1d711",
    "private_v3_case_sha256": "ad3b9531986446f73b1bc39e7b5baca2bedb1efdeb8ece06b7175008655fc2c6"
  },
  "structure": {
    "pages": 22,
    "blocks": 206,
    "statement_propositions": 276,
    "paragraph_composites": 206,
    "review_records": 482
  },
  "source_integrity": {
    "native_hash_bound": true,
    "pages_represented": "22/22",
    "preserved_review_anchors": "482/482",
    "statement_scan": "276/276"
  },
  "provisional_v3_statement_states": {
    "UNRESOLVED": 200,
    "RHETORICAL_OR_LEGAL": 64,
    "PARTIAL": 10,
    "SUPPORTED": 2
  },
  "candidate_scan": {
    "statements_with_one_or_more_markers": 179,
    "statement_denominator": 276,
    "candidate_load_percent": 64.9,
    "marker_instances": 271,
    "rules": {
      "CI-001": {
        "label": "Exact quote/context comparison",
        "count": 57
      },
      "CI-025": {
        "label": "Actor/capacity separation",
        "count": 56
      },
      "CI-012": {
        "label": "Quantifier/generalisation",
        "count": 56
      },
      "CI-016": {
        "label": "Causation bridge",
        "count": 41
      },
      "CI-007": {
        "label": "Recontextualisation/context restoration",
        "count": 27
      },
      "CI-014": {
        "label": "Knowledge timing",
        "count": 15
      },
      "CI-034": {
        "label": "Numeric precision",
        "count": 13
      },
      "CI-019": {
        "label": "Character attack vs proposition",
        "count": 4
      },
      "CI-021": {
        "label": "Procedural/finality state",
        "count": 2
      }
    },
    "pages": {
      "1": {
        "candidates": 5,
        "propositions": 10
      },
      "2": {
        "candidates": 5,
        "propositions": 5
      },
      "3": {
        "candidates": 15,
        "propositions": 16
      },
      "4": {
        "candidates": 33,
        "propositions": 36
      },
      "5": {
        "candidates": 9,
        "propositions": 13
      },
      "6": {
        "candidates": 3,
        "propositions": 10
      },
      "7": {
        "candidates": 6,
        "propositions": 10
      },
      "8": {
        "candidates": 5,
        "propositions": 14
      },
      "9": {
        "candidates": 4,
        "propositions": 14
      },
      "10": {
        "candidates": 6,
        "propositions": 10
      },
      "11": {
        "candidates": 6,
        "propositions": 10
      },
      "12": {
        "candidates": 9,
        "propositions": 12
      },
      "13": {
        "candidates": 10,
        "propositions": 16
      },
      "14": {
        "candidates": 8,
        "propositions": 14
      },
      "15": {
        "candidates": 10,
        "propositions": 10
      },
      "16": {
        "candidates": 7,
        "propositions": 8
      },
      "17": {
        "candidates": 4,
        "propositions": 11
      },
      "18": {
        "candidates": 7,
        "propositions": 12
      },
      "19": {
        "candidates": 7,
        "propositions": 8
      },
      "20": {
        "candidates": 9,
        "propositions": 15
      },
      "21": {
        "candidates": 5,
        "propositions": 13
      },
      "22": {
        "candidates": 6,
        "propositions": 9
      }
    }
  },
  "source_complete_context_signoffs": 0,
  "signoff_denominator": 482,
  "worked_examples": [
    {
      "page": 2,
      "type": "false-positive control",
      "summary": "The filing itself says the 2023 classification judgment is under appeal; citing the first-instance judgment is not by itself a finality inversion."
    },
    {
      "page": 3,
      "type": "context-restoration target",
      "summary": "Hostile characterisations appear beside a reproduced project screenshot that visibly says matters remain 'No probado todavía'; later summaries should preserve that proof boundary."
    },
    {
      "page": 5,
      "type": "generalisation target",
      "summary": "The 2020 withdrawal/apology is real adverse evidence. It does not by itself establish a common reason for every lawyer transition; the v3 review records that broader causal inference as unsupported/incomplete."
    }
  ],
  "boundary": "Candidate markers are triage prompts and review-load measures, not findings of falsity, deception, intent, credibility, criminality, guilt or liability. Existing adverse evidence and lawful alternatives remain visible.",
  "updated_at": "2026-09-25",
  "visualization": {
    "fallback": "assets/r33-truth-machine-visual-20260925.svg",
    "width": 1920,
    "height": 1080,
    "vector": true,
    "dynamic_renderer": "assets/truth-machine-live.js",
    "refresh_seconds": 60
  },
  "scientific_method_pass": {
    "schema": "por-derecho.r33-forensic-method-pass.v1",
    "control": "PD-R33-METHOD-STACK-20260925-01",
    "document": {
      "id": "RPL3304-AC-OP-20260914-LLFULLV3",
      "title": "FULL Liar Liar v3 — Oposición del Administrador Concursal al recurso de apelación de Luchy Playa Blanca, S.L. · RPL 3304/2025",
      "native_sha256": "5e0728185cf9b686abd723497d2a53a2656a5e0de4d323a734ed02880eb1d711",
      "pages": 22
    },
    "scope_boundary": "Deterministic/documentary method pass over preserved v3 statement records. It creates review candidates and matrices, not a linguistic lie detector or automatic finding of falsity, knowledge, intent, guilt or liability.",
    "structure": {
      "blocks": 206,
      "statement_propositions": 276,
      "paragraph_composites": 206,
      "review_records": 482
    },
    "method_coverage": {
      "ACH_competing_hypotheses": {
        "processed": 276,
        "probabilities_assigned": 0,
        "states": {
          "NON_BINARY_EXCLUDED_FROM_FACTUAL_ACH": 64,
          "H1_TO_H5_OPEN_INSUFFICIENT_CURRENT_REVIEW": 200,
          "H2_NARROWER_THAN_USED_ACTIVE": 6,
          "H1_ACCURATE_CURRENTLY_HAS_SUPPORT": 2,
          "H2_OR_H4_NARROWING_OR_CONTRADICTION_ACTIVE": 4
        }
      },
      "SUE_statement_evidence_consistency": {
        "processed": 276,
        "states": {
          "NON_BINARY_RHETORIC_OR_LEGAL": 64,
          "OPEN_NOT_SOURCE_RESOLVED": 200,
          "PARTIAL_OR_NARROWING": 6,
          "CURRENTLY_SUPPORTED_IN_V3": 2,
          "MIXED_WITH_CONTRARY_RELATION": 4
        },
        "interview_strategy_simulated": false
      },
      "verifiability_approach": {
        "processed": 276,
        "with_one_or_more_objective_checkability_cues": 154,
        "cue_types": {
          "PROCEDURAL_OR_FILING_REF": 68,
          "DATE_OR_YEAR": 54,
          "NAMED_ACTOR_OR_ENTITY": 87,
          "DOCUMENT_OR_TRANSACTION_REF": 98,
          "AMOUNT_OR_PERCENT": 10,
          "LEGAL_PROVISION": 8
        },
        "truth_inference_from_ratio": false
      },
      "wigmore_evidence_graph": {
        "proposition_nodes": 276,
        "evidence_source_families": 14,
        "statement_evidence_edges": 491,
        "contrary_edges": 4,
        "source_families": [
          "PD-7JUNE-CONTROL",
          "PD-AC-FEES",
          "PD-CALIF-A01",
          "PD-CALIF-A04",
          "PD-CALIF-TRUTH-INVERSION",
          "PD-DEFENSE-CONTINUITY-20260921",
          "PD-GT-2020",
          "PD-GT-CUYAS",
          "PD-OBREM-2018",
          "PD-RICPE-SUNPARK",
          "PD-RPL3304-DOSSIER",
          "PD-VALENCIA-DOCUMENT-ROOM",
          "R17-LPB-APPEAL",
          "SRC-P03-IMG-LIMITS"
        ]
      },
      "FATF_parallel_financial_rail": {
        "processed": 276,
        "candidate_statements": 79,
        "cue_types": {
          "PAYMENT": 15,
          "DEBT_CREDIT": 35,
          "AMOUNT": 10,
          "ACCOUNT": 26,
          "INVOICE": 8
        },
        "completed_money_traces": 0
      },
      "FCA_expected_control_evidence": {
        "processed": 276,
        "candidate_statements": 91,
        "cue_types": {
          "FILING_NOTICE": 47,
          "AUTHORITY_APPROVAL": 22,
          "VALUATION_TRANSACTION": 11,
          "ACCOUNTING_RECORD": 20
        },
        "completed_control_artifact_reconciliations": 0
      },
      "FBI_linguistic_probe": {
        "processed": 276,
        "candidate_statements": 119,
        "cue_types": {
          "PROCEDURAL_STATE": 35,
          "HEDGE_MODAL": 13,
          "RHETORIC_ATTACK": 5,
          "ABSOLUTE_QUANTIFIER": 44,
          "NEGATION_DENIAL": 64,
          "CAUSAL_LANGUAGE": 24
        },
        "deception_findings": 0
      },
      "knowledge_intent_separation": {
        "knowledge_states": {
          "NOT_ASSESSED": 261,
          "INFERRED_ONLY": 15
        },
        "causation_states": {
          "NOT_ASSESSED": 235,
          "UNSUPPORTED_INFERENCE": 41
        },
        "knowingly_false_findings": 0
      },
      "falsehood_truth_inversion_register": {
        "states": {
          "NON_BINARY_RHETORIC_OR_LEGAL": 64,
          "OPEN_UNRESOLVED": 200,
          "NARROWING_OR_MISLEADING_USE_CANDIDATE": 6,
          "CURRENTLY_SUPPORTED": 2,
          "CONTRADICTION_REVIEW_CANDIDATE": 4
        },
        "contradiction_review_candidates": 4,
        "source_complete_falsehood_signoffs": 0,
        "knowingly_false_signoffs": 0
      }
    },
    "page_metrics": {
      "1": {
        "statements": 10,
        "verifiable": 6,
        "rhetorical_legal": 6,
        "linguistic": 5,
        "unresolved": 4,
        "control": 2,
        "financial": 1
      },
      "2": {
        "statements": 5,
        "financial": 4,
        "control": 3,
        "linguistic": 4,
        "unresolved": 3,
        "verifiable": 4,
        "rhetorical_legal": 2
      },
      "3": {
        "statements": 16,
        "verifiable": 7,
        "linguistic": 5,
        "rhetorical_legal": 3,
        "partial": 1,
        "financial": 2,
        "unresolved": 10,
        "control": 2,
        "supported": 2
      },
      "4": {
        "statements": 36,
        "verifiable": 12,
        "unresolved": 33,
        "rhetorical_legal": 3,
        "financial": 8,
        "linguistic": 8,
        "control": 4
      },
      "5": {
        "statements": 13,
        "verifiable": 7,
        "unresolved": 6,
        "linguistic": 6,
        "rhetorical_legal": 6,
        "control": 2,
        "contradiction_candidate": 1,
        "partial": 1
      },
      "6": {
        "statements": 10,
        "verifiable": 8,
        "control": 4,
        "linguistic": 8,
        "unresolved": 6,
        "financial": 2,
        "rhetorical_legal": 4
      },
      "7": {
        "statements": 10,
        "verifiable": 5,
        "control": 6,
        "linguistic": 5,
        "rhetorical_legal": 2,
        "unresolved": 8,
        "financial": 2
      },
      "8": {
        "statements": 14,
        "verifiable": 8,
        "financial": 6,
        "control": 8,
        "rhetorical_legal": 4,
        "unresolved": 10,
        "linguistic": 2
      },
      "9": {
        "statements": 14,
        "verifiable": 6,
        "control": 10,
        "linguistic": 6,
        "unresolved": 8,
        "financial": 9,
        "rhetorical_legal": 4,
        "contradiction_candidate": 2,
        "partial": 2
      },
      "10": {
        "statements": 10,
        "verifiable": 9,
        "control": 9,
        "unresolved": 8,
        "financial": 5,
        "linguistic": 4,
        "contradiction_candidate": 1,
        "partial": 1,
        "rhetorical_legal": 1
      },
      "11": {
        "statements": 10,
        "verifiable": 7,
        "financial": 2,
        "rhetorical_legal": 2,
        "control": 5,
        "linguistic": 5,
        "unresolved": 8
      },
      "12": {
        "statements": 12,
        "verifiable": 8,
        "partial": 1,
        "control": 3,
        "unresolved": 10,
        "linguistic": 3,
        "rhetorical_legal": 1,
        "financial": 2
      },
      "13": {
        "statements": 16,
        "unresolved": 15,
        "control": 2,
        "linguistic": 5,
        "verifiable": 6,
        "rhetorical_legal": 1
      },
      "14": {
        "statements": 14,
        "unresolved": 14,
        "verifiable": 7,
        "control": 4,
        "linguistic": 4,
        "financial": 2
      },
      "15": {
        "statements": 10,
        "unresolved": 5,
        "verifiable": 8,
        "control": 6,
        "rhetorical_legal": 5,
        "linguistic": 6,
        "financial": 2
      },
      "16": {
        "statements": 8,
        "verifiable": 8,
        "financial": 5,
        "rhetorical_legal": 4,
        "linguistic": 6,
        "unresolved": 4,
        "control": 2
      },
      "17": {
        "statements": 11,
        "financial": 10,
        "control": 4,
        "rhetorical_legal": 5,
        "verifiable": 8,
        "linguistic": 3,
        "unresolved": 6
      },
      "18": {
        "statements": 12,
        "linguistic": 7,
        "rhetorical_legal": 4,
        "verifiable": 8,
        "financial": 7,
        "control": 6,
        "unresolved": 8
      },
      "19": {
        "statements": 8,
        "verifiable": 7,
        "control": 3,
        "linguistic": 5,
        "unresolved": 6,
        "financial": 3,
        "rhetorical_legal": 1,
        "partial": 1
      },
      "20": {
        "statements": 15,
        "verifiable": 6,
        "control": 3,
        "linguistic": 10,
        "unresolved": 14,
        "partial": 1,
        "financial": 5
      },
      "21": {
        "statements": 13,
        "verifiable": 6,
        "linguistic": 7,
        "unresolved": 10,
        "control": 2,
        "rhetorical_legal": 1,
        "partial": 2
      },
      "22": {
        "statements": 9,
        "verifiable": 3,
        "linguistic": 5,
        "unresolved": 4,
        "rhetorical_legal": 5,
        "financial": 2,
        "control": 1
      }
    },
    "falsehood_register_candidates": [
      {
        "id": "RPL3304-AC-OP-20260914-LLFULLV3-P05-B053-S001",
        "page": 5,
        "v3_status": "PARTIAL",
        "contrary_sources": [
          {
            "source": "PD-DEFENSE-CONTINUITY-20260921",
            "locator": "Tabla 21-Sep-2026: motivos distintos documentados; no existe una causa única acreditada para todas las sustituciones"
          }
        ],
        "knowledge_state": "INFERRED_ONLY",
        "causation_state": "UNSUPPORTED_INFERENCE",
        "state": "CONTRADICTION_REVIEW_CANDIDATE_NOT_SIGNED_OFF"
      },
      {
        "id": "RPL3304-AC-OP-20260914-LLFULLV3-P09-B089-S001",
        "page": 9,
        "v3_status": "PARTIAL",
        "contrary_sources": [
          {
            "source": "PD-CALIF-A01",
            "locator": "Audit result: global non-collaboration portrayal materially narrowed/contradicted by AC sources; specific missing materials remain separate"
          }
        ],
        "knowledge_state": "NOT_ASSESSED",
        "causation_state": "UNSUPPORTED_INFERENCE",
        "state": "CONTRADICTION_REVIEW_CANDIDATE_NOT_SIGNED_OFF"
      },
      {
        "id": "RPL3304-AC-OP-20260914-LLFULLV3-P09-B091-S001",
        "page": 9,
        "v3_status": "PARTIAL",
        "contrary_sources": [
          {
            "source": "PD-CALIF-A01",
            "locator": "Audit result: global non-collaboration portrayal materially narrowed/contradicted by AC sources; specific missing materials remain separate"
          }
        ],
        "knowledge_state": "NOT_ASSESSED",
        "causation_state": "UNSUPPORTED_INFERENCE",
        "state": "CONTRADICTION_REVIEW_CANDIDATE_NOT_SIGNED_OFF"
      },
      {
        "id": "RPL3304-AC-OP-20260914-LLFULLV3-P10-B094-S001",
        "page": 10,
        "v3_status": "PARTIAL",
        "contrary_sources": [
          {
            "source": "PD-CALIF-A01",
            "locator": "Audit result: global non-collaboration portrayal materially narrowed/contradicted by AC sources; specific missing materials remain separate"
          }
        ],
        "knowledge_state": "NOT_ASSESSED",
        "causation_state": "UNSUPPORTED_INFERENCE",
        "state": "CONTRADICTION_REVIEW_CANDIDATE_NOT_SIGNED_OFF"
      }
    ],
    "validation": {
      "private_records_processed": 276,
      "statement_anchor_count": 276,
      "source_inputs_modified": false,
      "automatic_merits_promotions": 0
    }
  },
  "source_review_20260925": {
    "control": "PD-R33-METHOD-STACK-SOURCE-REVIEW-20260925-01",
    "principle": "Preserve historical v3 contradiction edges, then source-review proposition scope before promotion.",
    "reviewed": [
      {
        "id": "RPL3304-AC-OP-20260914-LLFULLV3-P05-B053-S001",
        "page": 5,
        "result": "MISLEADING_INFERENCE_OR_UNSUPPORTED_CAUSAL_GENERALISATION",
        "literal_falsehood_signed_off": false,
        "basis": [
          "evidence/insolvency-36-2012/rpl-3304-2025/R33-oposicion-ac-apelacion-lpb-septiembre-2026-controlled-extracts.md",
          "es/continuidad-defensa-letrados/index.html"
        ],
        "reason": "The 2020 withdrawal/apology is genuine adverse evidence but does not establish one common reason for all counsel transitions."
      },
      {
        "id": "RPL3304-AC-OP-20260914-LLFULLV3-P09-B089-S001",
        "page": 9,
        "result": "NARROWER_DOCUMENT_REQUEST_DISPUTE_LITERAL_FALSEHOOD_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
        "literal_falsehood_signed_off": false,
        "basis": [
          "archive/CALIFICACION_ALLEGATION_01_COLLABORATION_FALSEHOOD_LEDGER_16AUG2026.md"
        ],
        "reason": "The broader non-collaboration portrayal is materially narrowed, while specific delayed/missing documents remain documented."
      },
      {
        "id": "RPL3304-AC-OP-20260914-LLFULLV3-P09-B091-S001",
        "page": 9,
        "result": "NARROWER_ACCOUNTING_SUFFICIENCY_DISPUTE_LITERAL_FALSEHOOD_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
        "literal_falsehood_signed_off": false,
        "basis": [
          "archive/CALIFICACION_ALLEGATION_01_COLLABORATION_FALSEHOOD_LEDGER_16AUG2026.md",
          "archive/CALIFICACION_AC_REPORT_RADICAL_TRANSPARENCY_LEDGER_16AUG2026.md"
        ],
        "reason": "Accounting material was received, while statutory sufficiency/supporting-material disputes remained; request→delivery reconciliation is still required."
      },
      {
        "id": "RPL3304-AC-OP-20260914-LLFULLV3-P10-B094-S001",
        "page": 10,
        "result": "CAUSATION_SCOPE_MATERIALLY_NARROWED_LITERAL_FALSEHOOD_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
        "literal_falsehood_signed_off": false,
        "basis": [
          "archive/CALIFICACION_ALLEGATION_01_COLLABORATION_FALSEHOOD_LEDGER_16AUG2026.md",
          "archive/CALIFICACION_AC_REPORT_RADICAL_TRANSPARENCY_LEDGER_16AUG2026.md"
        ],
        "reason": "The global causal frame is materially narrowed by the AC's own cooperation/accounting record and the judgment; exact annual-account causation remains open."
      },
      {
        "id": "RPL3304-AC-OP-20260914-LLFULLV3-P19-20-B186-S001",
        "page": 19,
        "result": "ACCURATE_LIMITED_USE_WITH_SCOPE_MISMATCH_RISK",
        "literal_falsehood_signed_off": false,
        "basis": [
          "evidence/insolvency-36-2012/rpl-3304-2025/R33-oposicion-ac-apelacion-lpb-septiembre-2026-controlled-extracts.md"
        ],
        "reason": "Pre-appointment timing limits responsibility for origin but does not answer later notice, decisions or continuing effects, including the 2016 notice reproduced by R33."
      }
    ],
    "counts": {
      "reviewed_relations": 5,
      "direct_literal_falsehood_signoffs": 0,
      "misleading_or_scope_limited_source_reviews": 2,
      "narrowed_or_open_falsehood_reviews": 3,
      "knowingly_false_signoffs": 0
    },
    "next_finite_proof": [
      "request→response→delivery→missing-item matrix",
      "native-source review for six remaining PARTIAL/narrowing records",
      "actor-specific knowledge proof before any knowingly-false promotion"
    ]
  }
}